Comments/Ratings for a Single Item

One thing that might balance the odds would be to keep it a secret of which pawn holds the ring. Once the ring is captured, then its location would be revealed. This would fit better to the story.

That's a great idea. I've seen the <a href=http://www.chessvariants.com/multiplayer.dir/4players.html>Four-Handed Chess Variants</a> on plus-shaped boards criticized for their wide-open spaces and slow action (the Cincinnati 4-way article makes this criticism, for example). But, as the setting for an epic tale, the vastness and slow opening would be part of the charm. <p> I would consider Dessau (described in the Four-Handed Chess article) first. It has a plus-shaped board consisting of an 8x8 center to which four 3x8 rectangles have been appended, with the familiar Chess armies standing on the first two rows. The Ring would have to behave a little differently, since White needs to carry it sideways instead of forward. Instead of granting White the power to move one space straght or diagonally forward, it could be one space straight or diagonally toward Mordor. <p> I don't think I like how some of White's pawns are so much closer to the final goal than others. Maybe the Ring can only be destroyed on the far half of Mordor's back rank. <p> If I had more friends, I'd try it out. Thanks for the insight.

Another use for this ring could be to create some good three-player games. Take any game for four players, have one player move two opposite armies as White(Gondor and the North), and the other two players one army each as Black (Isengard and Mordor). This would balance the odds even better, as the player whose pieces are hampered by carrying the Ring would have twice the material, though at the price of a more awkward route to destroy the Ring. All this would also match the original story really well.