[ List Earliest Comments Only For Pages | Games | Rated Pages | Rated Games | Subjects of Discussion ]
Comments/Ratings for a Single Item
Just to be sure before I comment.... What variant of chess are you talking about. Spartan Chess?
Steven, it does not sound to me much like Spartan Chess. Team 1 is missing the queen; Team 2 has the usual army except for the doubled king; Team 2 loses if either of their kings is lost. This seems like a good thing to set up and run many games on a computer. I would guess that the double royals is more of a detriment than a benefit.
I am already doing that. Had to change Fairy-Max a little for it, because since I had it support Spartan Chess I switched it to applying extinction rules (with or without duple check) to the royals, rather than absolute royalty. But now I am running again with rules where loss of the first King is fatal. Will report when I have enough games. After 100 games the two Kings were leading by 52-48. This is not a significant difference, so it seems the extra King is just as much as a liability as an asset. (An extra Pawn would cause something like 68-32.) It makes little sense to try to measure this more precise without improving the strategy. The King pair has an obvious winning advantage in a Pawn ending, when no piece can threaten them anymore. (Although KK vs K is a draw, so the extra K is equivalent to an extra minor.) But in the middle game you get mated more easily, and even against just two Rooks the Kings are mated very easily (by a skewer or fork). So it seems obvious that the 2-King side must strive for trading, i.e. all pieces of the 1-King side should be considered worth somewhat more than the corresponding pieces of the 1-King side, because of the extra danger they represent to the King pair. As in the late end-game there will always be 2 vs 1 King, it becomes relatively important to know that KK vs K is draw, to avoid bungling wins by needless trading of the last Pawn. (The same holds for KB vs K and KN vs K in normal Chess, but these are quite rare, so that bungling those does not impact your score too much, while the Kings always survice to the end.)
This is not exactly a variant. Just 2 chess teams, they work with the usual chess rules, but with changes I said on my text. Anyway, I didnt even said what team is black or white, to not influence the values of the team. King is said to have infinite value, so those 2 teams came into my mind, one doenst have the queen (but can still promote to queen) and the other have an new king in the place of the queen. So one lost -9 points and one "gained infinite points".
5 comments displayed
Permalink to the exact comments currently displayed.