Check out Grant Acedrex, our featured variant for April, 2024.


[ Help | Earliest Comments | Latest Comments ]
[ List All Subjects of Discussion | Create New Subject of Discussion ]
[ List Earliest Comments Only For Pages | Games | Rated Pages | Rated Games | Subjects of Discussion ]

Single Comment

[Subject Thread] [Add Response]
Charles Gilman wrote on Wed, Aug 25, 2010 06:28 AM UTC:
You know how the Queen and Gnu and Cardinal and Canvasser are worth more than the sum of their parts because the unbound component unbinds the bound one? Well that led me to wonder about compounds whose diagonal or Camelwise move remains restricted to squares of a single colour. There could be a Queen that can move as a pale-square Bishop but not a dark-square one. Three questions strike me about such pieces:
1	Are they closer to being worth the sum of their parts? For example, is the restricted Queen described above worth a Rook plus a Bishop, or is it worth less because it can find itself on squares where it is temporarily only a Rook? How does it compare in strength to an Ajax or Ajaxrider Rook?
2	Are they worth cataloguing in my Man and Beast series? There are already two such pieces in use, the Korean pieces that are partway from General/Wazir to King/Prince, but they are something of a special case as they are further restricted to not leaving the Fortress. Can anyone see themselves using such pieces more widely?
3	If they are worth cataloguing, has anyone any ideas about how they should be named? I did have a brief idea for square-cell pieces, but thought better of it as I would prefer something more widely applicable. Should all pieces moving along the same subset of diagonals have the same prefix(es) or suffix(es), or should they be named according to whether the subset includes their own starting cell? What about the three colours of the hex board, and the overlapping Bishop and Unicorn bindings on a cubic board? What would you call a Governor restricted to Bishop moves including its starting cell but Unicorn ones not including it? How would you distinguish between a Waffle whose Elephant moves are confined to an entire Bishop binding, and to a mere Elephant one?